Toolhaus.org
Negative/Neutral Feedback received by fivestarauctions
Enter an eBay user ID:
    Allow over 1000 items (Why not?)
  False positives? (What's this?)
If you use Toolhaus, please consider supporting it!
Many thanks to our generous donors!
Default User image
This member's 12 month Feedback ratings
Member since: Dec-19-99 in United States
Recent feedback ratings (last 12 months)
 1 month6 months12 months
Positive feedback ratingPositive11412192242
Neutral feedback ratingNeutral001
Negative feedback ratingNegative002
12,868 Feedback received | Revised Feedback: 0
See this Seller's 30-Day Negs
 
 FeedbackFrom/priceDate/time
info
Detailed item information is not available for the following items because the Feedback is over 90 days old.
Neutral feedback ratingCase had a crack n wasn't described in listing! Buy at own risk!Buyer:
e***f ( 556Purple star icon for feedback score in between 500 to 999)
Nov-18-13 23:00
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Nov-19-13 14:24):
    Buyer never informed me of this problem. Sell to him at your own risk!
 2013 Bowman Chrome Carlos Correa BGS 9.5 Gem Black Refractor Rookie #/99 (#200969497445)US $46.00 
Negative feedback ratingPoor slow shipping, damaged item. waste of time/money. Buyer:
b***i ( 427Teal star icon for feedback score in between 100 to 499)
Aug-22-13 22:35
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Aug-26-13 12:49):
    Cards were sent in bubble mailer. Buyer said case was chipped, I offered refund
    • Follow-up by b***i (Sep-02-13 19:46):
      Ship it right and take responsibility. Own your mistakes dont waste my time!
 2013 Bowman Chrome Renato Nunez BGS 9.5 Gem 10 Auto Rookie Card - A's Prospect! (#190879962078)US $32.99 
Negative feedback ratingBad and slow shipping, damaged item.Buyer:
b***i ( 427Teal star icon for feedback score in between 100 to 499)
Aug-22-13 22:33
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Aug-26-13 12:50):
    Cards went from CA to IL in 4 business days. Please ignore this jerk buyer.
    • Follow-up by b***i (Sep-02-13 19:40):
      Card was not even shipped for 4 business days and was damaged. rude seller
 2013 Bowman Chrome Renato Nunez BGS 9.5 Gem 10 Auto Rookie Card - A's Prospect! (#200949362610)US $32.99 
Neutral feedback ratinglarge crack in case.seller offered refund but should not hide damage to itemBuyer:
n***9 ( 235Teal star icon for feedback score in between 100 to 499)
Mar-23-13 06:47
 2007 Bowman Sterling Jason Heyward BGS 9 Mint 10 Auto Rookie Card! (#190802735593)US $49.99 
Negative feedback ratingPOOR QUALITY. SHIPPED PRODUCT WAS RUINED. SELLER NO HELP AT ALL!Buyer:
g***n ( 2377Red star icon for feedback score in between 1,000 to 4,999)
Mar-01-13 11:27
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Mar-10-13 22:19):
    I offered full refund to buyer. He declined but left me this. What a jerk.
 Lot of 17 Horror / Thriller DVDs - Saw II, III, The Ring, The Box, Wolf Creek (#190795337018)US $21.73 
Neutral feedback ratingBait and switch, sent card with different sub grades than the one in the pictureBuyer:
t***j ( 1101Red star icon for feedback score in between 1,000 to 4,999)
Dec-01-12 04:18
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Dec-02-12 14:51):
    I made a mistake and offered a full refund. What more could I have done?
 2012 Bowman Chrome Jorge Soler BGS 9.5 Gem 10 Auto Rookie with Great Subs! (#200852052493)US $89.99 
Neutral feedback ratingBGS Case was cracked,Seller offered refund but refused to discount another card.Buyer:
y***1 ( 553Purple star icon for feedback score in between 500 to 999)
Jul-24-12 21:02
 2012 Bowman Chrome Oscar Taveras BGS 9.5 Gem 10 Auto Rookie Card! (#190694715223)US $109.99 
Neutral feedback ratingNever got the packs although advertised as "GUARANTEED". He refunded howeverBuyer:
3***3 ( 4065Red star icon for feedback score in between 1,000 to 4,999)
Jun-22-12 22:12
 2012 Bowman Baseball Blue Wave Wrapper Redemption Pack Pre-Sale- Guaranteed! (#190678173289)US $11.99 
Neutral feedback ratingNever got the packs although advertised as "GUARANTEED". He refunded howeverBuyer:
3***3 ( 4065Red star icon for feedback score in between 1,000 to 4,999)
Jun-22-12 22:12
 2012 Bowman Baseball Blue Wave Wrapper Redemption Pack Pre-Sale- Guaranteed! (#190678173289)US $11.99 
Negative feedback ratingDon't know if I'll ever get the card I bought, buyer beware, waited over 30 daysBuyer:
o***r ( 542Purple star icon for feedback score in between 500 to 999)
Nov-27-11 12:34
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Nov-27-11 20:51):
    At first I made a mistake but I did ultimately send the card. Problem solved.
 2011 Bowman Chrome Stetson Allie Blue Auto BGS 9 Rookie (#190587991034)US $24.99 
Neutral feedback ratingNice card, but the year on PSA says 1967.Buyer:
k***l ( 665Purple star icon for feedback score in between 500 to 999)
Nov-27-11 10:39
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Nov-27-11 20:48):
    That's an issue for PSA, not for me. Buyer received the exact card pictured.
 1958 Topps Mickey Mantle #150 PSA 4 (#190595525987)US $199.99 
Negative feedback ratingsent me a hundred dollar card in a broken case refused to send me a new caseBuyer:
l***s ( 3 )
Oct-16-11 12:32
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Oct-16-11 13:43):
    I offered refund and exchange. BGS has cases. I don't. Block this buyer. Nuts
 1993 Upper Deck SP Derek Jeter BCCG 9 Rookie Card! (#200657930100)US $94.95 
Neutral feedback ratingTook too longBuyer:
r***d ( 103Teal star icon for feedback score in between 100 to 499)
Oct-05-11 21:00
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Oct-06-11 19:33):
    That the USPS took 8 days is not my fault. Tracking #9101128882300888767124
 2001 Topps Traded Albert Pujols PSA 9 Mint Rookie Card! (#190571237185)US $79.99 
Negative feedback ratingROTTEN Seller.Does NOT ship items, LIES according to all NEGATIVE FEEDBACKBuyer:
m***u ( 5660Green star icon for feedback score in between 5,000 to 9,999)
May-31-11 09:56
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (May-31-11 14:15):
    This is feedback extortion and should be removed. My rating speaks for itself.
    • Follow-up by m***u (Jun-01-11 12:36):
      NOT extortion,COMPLETE TRUTH.Did you send the card?NO!!! Once again,SELLER LIES!
 1990 Topps Sammy Sosa PSA 9 Mint Rookie Card! (#190514784920)US $1.99 
Negative feedback ratingSmudge on the card not shown in picture or mentioned in descriptionBuyer:
d***a ( 80Blue star icon for feedback score in between 50 to 99)
Feb-25-11 17:53
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Feb-26-11 23:33):
    I offered full refund and buyer never responded. Now I get this feedback? Lame.
 2010 Topps Red Hot Rookies Stephen Strasburg - RARE! (#190496995649)US $13.99 
Negative feedback ratingVery Unprofessional and RUDE! Blames me for him sending me damaged item! BewareBuyer:
d***i ( 1194Red star icon for feedback score in between 1,000 to 4,999)
Jan-10-11 22:20
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Jan-11-11 14:57):
    I offered a partial refund and an exchange. Buyer took $$ and still complains.
    • Follow-up by d***i (Jan-12-11 00:00):
      You are a LIAR! I paid $100, received damaged card, he offers $5 refund? Avoid!
 2005 Bowman Sterling Ryan Braun Autograph BGS 9.5 Gem! (#200556682143)US $99.99 
Neutral feedback ratingI am very disappointed in this purchase.the card is a series 2.not 1.Buyer:
0***0 ( 144Teal star icon for feedback score in between 100 to 499)
Nov-01-10 16:33
 2007-08 Upper Deck Jonathan Toews BGS BCCG 10 RC! (#190457047548)US $64.99 
Neutral feedback ratingGood deal until I got cards and werent in sleeves/holders very unprofessionalBuyer:
n***3 ( 1751Red star icon for feedback score in between 1,000 to 4,999)
Aug-02-10 12:31
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Aug-02-10 15:07):
    The vast majority of cards in the lot were in a sleeve and top loader. Period.
    • Follow-up by n***3 (Aug-03-10 10:06):
      Wow that is a bold faced lie...no card holders period and only a few had sleeves
 PREMIUM GU AUTO RC INSERT STAR #'D LOT COLLECTION! (#200490201027)US $43.00 
Neutral feedback ratingPaid $134.00 ($20.00 shipping) and couldnt even put the cards in penny sleeves ?Buyer:
n***3 ( 1751Red star icon for feedback score in between 1,000 to 4,999)
Aug-02-10 12:31
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Aug-02-10 15:09):
    The vast majority of cards in this lot were in a sleeve and top loader. Period.
    • Follow-up by n***3 (Aug-03-10 10:07):
      An absolute lie...no top holders at all and only a few had sleeves buyer beware
 PREMIUM GU AUTO RC INSERT STAR #'D LOT COLLECTION! (#200490196042)US $71.00 
Negative feedback ratingHalf the cards weren't even sleeved AVOID BEWARE OVERCHARGED SHIPPING!~Buyer:
c***e ( 629Purple star icon for feedback score in between 500 to 999)

No longer a registered user
Aug-01-10 20:04
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Aug-02-10 15:01):
    I promptly offered this buyer a full refund and he would not accept. Oh well.
 PREMIUM GU AUTO RC INSERT STAR #'D LOT COLLECTION! (#200496631098)US $25.00 
Positive feedback ratingThis comment has been removed by eBay. Learn more.Seller: Mar-19-10 14:01
 ---- 
Negative feedback ratingI bought some cards and never got them.Buyer:
r***u ( 396Teal star icon for feedback score in between 100 to 499)
Sep-18-06 14:37
 -- (#200011251926)-- 
Negative feedback ratingDon't Buy from this Guy!! Bought a card and never Received it! Rip Off !!!!!!!!!Buyer:
r***n ( 212Teal star icon for feedback score in between 100 to 499)
Sep-17-06 09:12
 -- (#200011256999)-- 
Neutral feedback rating$2.50 s/h for a 39 cent stamped regular envelope....card overgraded ding=mint?Buyer:
f***r ( 1339Red star icon for feedback score in between 1,000 to 4,999)
Aug-17-06 19:26
 -- (#200012468170)-- 
Negative feedback ratinglots of dupes not as described failed to refund or replace slow emails !!Buyer:
n***y ( 408Teal star icon for feedback score in between 100 to 499)
Nov-28-04 16:08
  • Reply by fivestarauctions (Dec-01-04 04:34):
    Item exactly as described. EXACTLY! His feedback statement is a lie.
 -- (#5133824897)-- 
Neutral feedback ratingLotta dups=got 4-4-3-3 of 17 minor league nobodys..others so-so, nothing greatBuyer:
d***e ( 761Purple star icon for feedback score in between 500 to 999)
Nov-16-04 21:05
 -- (#5133815624)-- 
Neutral feedback ratingGood communications,Steep but Quick shipping, lot so-so, too many low endersBuyer:
t***c ( 979Purple star icon for feedback score in between 500 to 999)
Jul-20-04 13:20
 -- (#5106998540)-- 
Neutral feedback ratingProduct - good - Postmark was two after I paid for it.Buyer:
n***0 ( 64Blue star icon for feedback score in between 50 to 99)
Dec-16-03 11:39
 -- (#2768531558)-- 
Neutral feedback ratingPERSON NEVER LEFT ME A FEEDBACK May-08-01 10:55
 ---- 
Negative feedback ratingheld USPO MO for 2-3 weeks prior to shipping and poor communication ref shipping
No longer a registered user
Feb-11-01 19:03
  • Reply by o***a (Jan-01-01 00:00):
    I informed buyer that shipping would be delayed and shipped as soon as I could.
 ---- 
13Negative
16Neutral
1Withdrawn (1 removed by eBay)
30Total

That took 0:07 (user 0.42, sys 0.03)
Created with vi whb@toolhaus.org
negs ver. 7.65, Last modified 2014/07/19 19:24:14 (UTC)